Family History, Carter Davis Chart 0403 Domincus Carter, Lydia Smith, Sophronia Babcock, Sylvia Ameretta Meacham, Mary Ette Durfee, Eliza Babcock, Polly Milner, Elizabeth Brown, Caroline Marie Hubbard, Frances Nash and William Henry Davis

1830 Newry, Oxford, Maine, USA. Males - 20 thru 29: 1; Females - 20 thru 29: 1; Females - Under 5: 1
1840 Not found (Only a Joseph W in Hampden, Penobscot, Maine, USA, See 1850) Males - 5 thru 9: 1; 30 thru 39: 1; 40 thru 49: 1 Females - Under 5: 1; 10 thru 14: 1; 15 thru 19: 1 30 thru 39: 1)
1850 Hampden, Penobscot, Maine, USA. All CARTERs born Maine, USA. Joseph W CARTER (52) Farmer; Dominicus CARTER (46); Ann F CARTER (22); Allen
CARTER (17) Farmer; Hellen M CARTER (13); Dorinda CARTER (10); Francis CARTER (4); Jane FOWLER (50) born New Hampshire, USA (No occupation entered for Dominicus)
BUT ALSO..
1850 Pottawattamie, Iowa, USA. Dominicus CARTER (44) Blacksmith born Maine, Mary (20) (wife?) born New York, Sidney (14) born Maine, Lydia (12) born Ohio all places USA and Polly MINOR (18) (Sidney and Lydia were children of wife Lydia SMITH)
1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12) Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer) Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of Polly MILNER), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (76) born Maine, USA. Elizabeth CARTER (45) Keeping House, born New York, USA; Ilus CARTER at Home (9) and John F. CARTER (16) Works on Farm both born Utah, USA. Living either side of him were sons Edmund and Heber, sons of Mary DURFEE
Encyclopedic History of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Utah Stake of Zion
The early settlers in Utah County were much troubled with Indian depredations during the years 1850–1857 and an efficient military organization, known as the Utah County Militia, was organized, which rendered efficient service in protecting the settlers. In 1852 Apostle George A. SMITH was called by the authorities of the Church to locate at Provo and preside over the colony. He chose Isaac Higbee and Dominicus CARTER as his counsellors.
Utah Western Railroad
Following is a list of the principal officers of Utah Stake .from the time of its organization as Provo Stake in 1851 to the present time: Presidents: Isaac HIGBEE, 1851-1852; George A. SMITH 1852-1854; Isaac HIGBEE (2nd term), 1854-1855; James C. SNOW, 1855-1858; Dominicus CARTER (acting), 1858-1860; William MILLER, 1860-1868; Abraham O. SMOOT, 1868-1895 (died March 6, 1895); Edward PARTRIDGE, 1895-1900 (died Nov. 17, 1900); David JOHN, 1901-1908; Joseph B. KEELER, 1908-1919, and Thomas N. TAYLOR, 1919-1930. First counsellors: John BLACKBURN, 1851-1852; Isaac HIGBEE, 1852-1854; Dominicus Carter, 1855-1858; George W. Bean, 1860-1868; William MILLER, 1868 Aug., 1875 (died); David JOHN, 1877-1901; Joseph B. KEELER, 1901-1908; Lafayette HOLBROOK, 1908=1911, and J. Wm. KNIGHT, 1911-1930. Second counsellors: Thomas WILLIS, 1851-1852; Dominicus CARTER, 1852-1854; James N. JONES, 1855-1860; Isaac BULLOCK, 1860-1868; Elijah F. SHEETS, 1868-1873; Harvey H. CLUFF, 1877-1892; Edward PARTRIDGE, 1892-1895; Reed SMOOT, 1895-1900; Stephen L. CHIPMAN, 1900–-1901; Lafayette HOLBROOK, 1901-1908; J. Wm. KNIGHT, 1908-1911; Amos N. MERRILL, 1911-1919, and Simon P. EGGERTSEN, 1919-1930. Among the stake clerks may be mentioned Albert JONES, 1877-1884; James W. BEAN, 1884-1900; Lars N. NILSON, 1900-1902, and Edward Henry HOLT, 1902-1930.
Information from findagrave web site
Born in humble circumstances in Scarborough, Cumberland county, Maine, Dominicus CARTER was the son of John and Hannah Knight Libby CARTER. His father was a farmer, and Dominicus along with the rest of the family worked the farm. He had no formal schooling, but he did learn the trade of blacksmithing.
He married Lydia SMITH in 1828 and a few years later they joined the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. (Some records have 30 June 1832, others have 30 June 1834.) They moved to Kirtland (it appears they were in Kirtland by 1834) where he "had the privilege of hearing and listening to the teachings of the Prophet Joseph SMITH"
In 1838 Dominicus and Lydia Smith CARTER were a part of Kirtland Camp, the large wagon train that made the exodus from Kirtland to Missouri. While travelling, they lost their two-year-old daughter Sarah Emily. Then, twenty days after arriving in Far West, Lydia died, leaving Dominicus with four children. The following month, November of 1838, he married Sophronia BABCOCK. Together they endured the trials of expulsion from Missouri.
In 1839 Dominicus took his first plural wife, Sylvia Ameret MEACHAM, and in 1844 he took another – Mary DURFEE. He also was married to Sophronia BABCOCK's younger sister Eliza BABCOCK. It appears that Dominicus and Eliza were married in 1846 during the Nauvoo period, but she was back with her mother soon after as evidenced by the Winter Quarters Wards Membership Lists. Eliza crossed the plains as Eliza BABCOCK, and in 1855 she married John GROVES.
Dominicus was living near Nauvoo when the Prophet Joseph SMITH and his brother Hyrum were killed.
The trials of those days are well known and don't need to be repeated. It is said that Dominicus intended to leave with the early emigrants for the West, but he was asked to stay in Nauvoo and build wagons. He also worked on the Nauvoo temple and was one of those who received the blessings of that temple in December of 1845. Eventually they joined the body of the saints in Winter Quarters, but Sophronia died in childbirth on the plains on 26 August 1847.
In 1851 Dominicus, his wives and his six living children finally arrived in Salt Lake City. They moved to Provo in October of that year. But Sylvia MEACHAM decided that she didn't like the life of the polygamist wife and divorced him. It's unclear exactly when she left, but they had to be together for the conception of their son Isaac Morley, who was born in June of 1851 and died while they were crossing the plains. They had no more children together (see her bio) and Sylvia married her 2nd husband on 3 Nov 1855, so she was divorced from Dominicus by then.
Once Dominicus was settled in Provo, he took four more wives:
Polly MINER 1851
Elizabeth BROWN 1852
Caroline Maria HUBBARD 1854 (divorced in 1861)
Frances NASH 1857
Among his descendants, much is made of Dominicus Carter's nine wives, but before he ever came west he had already lost two of those wives, and three others chose to leave. During most of the Provo years he lived with four wives: Mary DURFEE, Polly MINER, Elizabeth BROWN and Fannie NASH. At his death all four of those women were at his bedside. By the count of his grand daughter Hannah Clark PIKE, he had "46 children, 17 of whom preceded him in death, 87 grandchildren and 41 great grandchildren." (The book "Carter Pioneers of Provo Utah" says he had 52 children, but there are several known mistakes in that list.)
Dominicus CARTER was described as a high-spirited man and a respected citizen of Provo:
He was First Counselor to President George A. SMITH of the Utah Stake.
He served on the Provo City Council.
He was a Probate Judge for four years.
He was a good singer and in the early days led the singing in Provo.
He helped organize a band which furnished music for the early militia and was their leader for twenty years.
During the 1880s, when polygamists were hunted and tried, many men went into hiding - but Dominicus CARTER stood his ground. As a result, he served time in the state penitentiary. He was in his seventies.
In the history that Hannah Clark PIKE wrote about her grandfather, she said this: "For years he ran a blacksmith shop in Provo. I remember as a girl seeing him put the oxen in an old wood frame to shoe them. He and his older sons also ran a hostelry. I remember seeing the stages drive in, they would run out and change the horses. Sometimes the stage would hurry away and at other times they would remain and go to my father's large home and eat. He always lived in Provo, owning a great deal of property. His homes, blacksmith shop and hostelry were between 1st and 2nd North, 5th West and from 4th West to 5th West and 1st North, Provo. He died as he always lived, a true Latter-day Saint. While on his death bed he called his family around him and gave them many sacred charges for their guidance through life. He bore a strong testimony to the divine mission of the Prophet Joseph SMITH and advised his posterity to abide in his faith."
Donated by: Vauna Marie KELLY

Lydia SMITH was Dominicus CARTER's first wife - the wife of his youth. After she and her husband joined the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, they removed to Kirtland, Ohio. A few years later she joined with her husband in the "Kirtland Camp" - the large wagon train that in 1838 made its way from Kirtland to Missouri. While traveling, they lost their two-year- old daughter Sarah Emily, and buried her on the trail.
The book "Carter Pioneers of Provo Utah" picks up the story:
"The camp arrived at their destination on 4 [October]. Persecution and massacres were a frequent occurrence, and mobs preyed on the community. During this time Lydia, wife of Dominicus CARTER, was confined. When the baby was but five days old, she was ordered by a mob with blackened faces to vacate her home by midnight, as they were going to burn it. she went into a nearby woods with her children and remained there throughout the night. There was a cold heavy rainfall and as a result of this exposure so soon after the birth of her baby she took cold and passed away shortly after on 23 Oct. Her children were scattered among the relatives."
[The only problem with this narrative is that there is no record of a child being born to Lydia in October of 1838, and it had been less than eight months since the reported birth of daughter Lydia Ann in February 1838.]
Lydia Smith CARTER was buried in the Far West Burial Ground. On the day of her death "the citizens of Ray county... appealed to the governor of the state, to give the people of Upper Missouri protection from the fearful body of thieves and robbers" (the Mormons). Four days later Governor BOGGS issued his extermination order.
Daughter of Johnathan SMITH & Lydia BROWN.
Dominicus and Lydia Smith CARTER had six children together: Arlytia Long, Lucinda McKenney, Barret (who died young), Sidney Rigdon, Sarah Emily, and Lydia Ann.

Information from findagrave website
From the book "Carter Pioneers of Provo Utah," we read:
"Family legend, handed down by word of mouth through some four or five generations, tells us that when Sophronia's child was to be born a doctor could not be found. Not even an experienced midwife was available to aid her in the delivery of the child at the makeshift campsite on the plains... Apparently it was not a normal parturition for it is retold that as the pain and agony became more intense and unbearable Sophronia clutched the spokes of a wagon wheel and braced herself with all of her waning strength, screaming uncontrollably during the ordeal. The hemorrhage could not be stopped and she died as a few family members stood by helpless. She and her unnamed child were buried in an unmarked grave on the lonely Iowa prairie beside the Carter wagon wheel tracks."
Burial:
Non-Cemetery Burial
Specifically: Buried on the plains near Kanesville (modern-day Council Bluffs, Iowa)

1850 Not found
1860 Great Salt Lake City Ward 17, Great Salt Lake, Utah Territory, USA . With new husband and family. Erastus was entered as SNIDER
Information from findagrave website
My 3rd great grandmother. She was a Utah Pioneer, crossing the plains in 1851.
Sylvia was married to Dominicus CARTER on 23 Mar 1839. Together they had two children: Eratus Francis CARTER & Isaac Morley CARTER. Polygamy didn't work for her and they divorced.
On 3 Nov 1855 she married John SNIDER, who was a widower. A history of Sylvia's son Erastus Francis CARTER says that John SNIDER "was a grand man and a good father to Erastus." She had two children with John SNIDER: Martin Henry SNIDER & John Hyrum SNIDER.
CHILDREN: Many sources attribute several additional children to Sylvia MEACHAM & Dominicus CARTER, but these children (Harriett, Arthur, Nellie, Louisa, and Amelia) were all born many years after Sylvia left Dominicus. Harriet is documented to be the daughter of Polly MINER. Arthur and Louisa are documented to be the children of Frances NASH. On the list that was purportedly copied from Dominicus Carter's own records Nellie was attributed to Frances NASH, but she is not on the list of children that Frances NASH's mother made. Amelia is attributed to Sylvia MEACHAM in the book "Carter Pioneers of Provo Utah," but she was born more than a decade after Sylvia had left Dominicus. It is possible that Amelia is actually Cornelia, a daughter of Dominicus and Mary DURFEE who was buried 27 August 1867 in the Provo cemetery. Sylvia MEACHAM WAS NOT the mother of these children.
Daughter of Stephen Peabody Meacham & Dorothy Maria Ransom.

1850 Pottawattamie, Iowa, USA. Dominicus CARTER (44) Blacksmith born Maine, Mary (20) (wife?) born New York, Sidney (14) born Maine, Lydia (12) born Ohio all places USA and Polly MINOR (18) (Sidney and Lydia were children of wife Lydia SMITH)
1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of
Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) born New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.

From findagrave web site
Dominicus CARTER also was married to Sophronia BABCOCK's younger sister Eliza BABCOCK. It appears that Dominicus and Eliza were married in 1846 during the Nauvoo period, but she was back with her mother soon after as evidenced by the Winter Quarters Wards Membership Lists. Eliza crossed the plains as Eliza BABCOCK, and in 1855 she married John GROVES

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Living one side of Polly and the children were Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Polly was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer)..anNext door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) born New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of
Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home" Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living one side of Elizabeth was:
Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Elizabeth was: Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (76) born Maine, USA Elizabeth CARTER (45) Keeping House, born New York, USA; Ilus CARTER at Home (9) and John F. CARTER (16) Works on Farm both born Utah, USA

1850 Des Moines, Polk, Iowa, USA. Living with John and Caroline there was a Mary NEELY (16) born Ohio, USA
1860 Provo, Utah, Utah Territory, USA as Batie. Living with them were CARTER children with surname BATIE. Also living with them was Ellisha HUBBARD (23) Teamster born Michigan and
1860 Grantsville, Tooele, Utah Territory, USA, no husband present Living with Caroline HUBBARD all the PERRY and CARTER children had the
name HUBBARD William BEATTY (30) Comml Labourer born New York, USA was living with them as well as Elisha (22) Farm Labourer born Michigan, USA and Marshall HUBBARD (14) born Illinois, USA
1870 Grantsville, Tooele, Utah Territory, USA with husband Amos FENSTERMAKER. Living with them were Caroline's PERRY daughters and son William BEATTY
1880 Grantsville, Tooele, Utah Territory, USA
1900 Grantsville, Tooele, Utah Territory, USA . Living with them was Servant John Fred NELSON (21) born April 1879 Sweden. On the 1900 census Caroline is shown as having had 8 children, all still living
Information from findagrave web site
Caroline was married 4 times:
Caroline HUBBARD was Dominicus CARTER's 7th wife. They had two children together and divorced. The book "Carter Pioneers of Provo Utah" states that she divorced him 25 Jan 1861. In 1866 she married Amos FENSTERMAKER.
Caroline Hubbard FENSTERMAKER died of pneumonia. Her death certificate says she was buried at the South Cottonwood Cemetery, which according to the Utah State Historical Society Burials Database is the original name for the Murray City Cemetery.
Information for William Crawford BEATTIE
The history behind William's first wife reads like this:
At the age of (16) CAROLINE MARIA HUBBARD (daughter to Marshall Moore Hubbard & Caroline Eliza NICKERSON) marries 1st JOHN MARCELLUS PERRY on Dec 23, 1849 in Des Moines, Polk, la, (Having (2) children: Eliza Clarissa & Emma Orilla). John dies at the age of (33) in 1854, only being married for (5) years.
Caroline re-marries a 2nd time to DOMINICUS CARTER (a Mormon Polygamist) at the age of (21) on Oct 20 1854, becoming his 8th wife (Having (2) children: Willard & Clara Melissa). Her parents had joined the Mormon church in 1833, agreeing to this practice of plural marriage and becoming a God after death, according the Mormon belief. (The Mormon church was established by Joseph Smith in 1830). Mr. CARTER's life style was more than he (?she) could assume. At this time Caroline was working at a molasses mill about 3 miles away from home. Her work required her to skim the light foam substance from the molasses. She was paid a small amount of molasses, which served as part of their families winter food. The plural wives had to work hard at home to support their families. Caroline became discourage with this polygamist life style. It was this deciding factor that ruined the marriage. So Caroline divorces Dominicus CARTER in January 1860, at the age of (27).
She re-married a 3rd time to WILLIAM CRAWFORD BEATTIE, and together they have a son William Marcellus Beattie: Sep 15 1861, but later divorces William and ...
re-marries yet a 4th time to AMOS FENSTERMAKER at the age of (33) on July 07, 1866 in Provo, Utah. This is Caroline last marriage signifying her last name as "FENSTERMAKER". Amos & Caroline had (3) children:
1-Charles Henry Hubbard FENSTERMAKER/
2-Perry Raymond Hubbard FENSTERMAKER/
3-David Amos (Jack) FENSTERMAKER
William lived in the same household with Caroline E. NICKERSON (Caroline Maria HUBBARD's mother). Caroline M. HUBBARD was married twice before she married William. Elisha HUBBARD (only son of 4 children) mother to Caroline E. NICKERSON's and Caroline M. HUBBARDs brother, became business partners with William in a freighting business. They moved shortly after William & Caroline had a baby boy named WILLIAM MARCELLUS BEATTIE, born Sep 18 1861, moving to either Arizona or California. In fact, there is (was) a town named HUBBARD, where Elisha settled.
Family lore says that William went to town one day and never came home. According to other family sources, William loaded his wagon with fruits/ vegetables to sell at the market on a morning in Oct. 1861, while he/Caroline Mariah lived in a small farm near Provo, UT. He left that morning and was never heard of again. Some time later his wagon was found upturned in some rocks by the Provo River, but William, the produce, and horses that pulled the wagon were gone and never seen again.
Caroline and her children return to Utah by 1865. She remarries the 4th time to AMOS FENSTERMAKER. William Marcellus BEATTIE thus lives with her and the other relatives until he is about age (15); at which point he and his mother have a fall out. He decides to leave home and from then on he supports himself, eventually settling in Idaho.
After divorcing Caroline Maria HUBBARD, William Crawford BEATTIE Re-Married a 2nd time: EVELINE BELLE CARTER on September 16, 1856 in Lafayette Co., Missouri.
There are two dates on findagrave for the divorce, 1860 and 1861. As Caroline was with her new husband, William BEATTIE on the 1860 census I am assuming the 1860 date is the right one.

1841 Mill Lane, St Mary the Virgin, Guildford, Surrey
1851 6 Market Place, Guildford Holy Trinity, Surrey
1855 “On a Family Tree there is a Passenger List for Siddons ship which appears to have been a Mormon crossing in February 1855 which lists George his wife Elizabeth and Frances.”
1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah All except Fanny née NASH born USA Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home" Frances (33) born England with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of Polly MILNER), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances). Living next to Frances was: Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7) Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living next to her was Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA, Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home(No confirmation as yet that Samuel or Parley belong to Frances, all children shown
with mother born Utah, but Arthur shows mother born England on a later census). Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER, Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. LIving in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James
1900 Provo, Utah, USA

1900 Provo, Utah, USA1912 His death certificate gives his parents' names as Henry Davis & Maria Sutton.

1850 Great Salt Lake, Utah Territory, USA. Martin PECK with: wife Mary and children James (18) born Vermont, USA, William (16) born Vermont,
USA both Farmers, Hezikiah (6) born Illinois, USA and Lucien (1) born Des, Salt Lake City, Utah Territory, USA and William (30) Farmer...... and wife Arlylia (22) born Maine, USA and children Lucius (2) born Indiana Territory, USA and Martin H and Mary Amor (twins) (7/12) born Des, Salt Lake City, Utah, Territory, USA

1850 Pottawattamie, Iowa, USA. Living next door to her father (who is also entered as living elsewhere) and family
From findagrave web site
Erza Houghton CURTIS first marriage was on the 18th Dec 1846 in Mount Pisgah, Iowa to Lucinda CARTER, who was born 14th Jan 1831 in Oxford, Maine. She died on 26 Jan 1904 in Aurora and was the daughter of Dominicus CARTER and Lydia SMITH. They have two children born in Council Bluffs, Iowa, then came to Utah in 1851. They settled in Provo where they lived until 1875 when Ezra and his sons moved to Aurora [Willow Bend].
Inscription:
In Memory Of. Beloved Wife of Ezra H. Curtis. "She Was A Kind And Affectionate Wife, A Fond Mother, And A Friend To All."

1850 Not found
Information on findagrave website
Family records say he died young. I have not located him on any census records, so may have died as a child

1850 Pottawattamie, Iowa, USA. Dominicus CARTER (44) Blacksmith born Maine, Mary (20) (wife?) born New York, Sidney (14) born Maine, Lydia (12) born Ohio all places USA and Polly MINOR (18). (Sidney and Lydia were children of wife Lydia SMITH)
1860 Provo, Utah, Utah Territory, USA with two wives Margaret and Mary, but not Leah
1870 Kanoch, Millard, Utah Territory, USA with Leah
1880 Joseph, Sevier, Utah, USA with Leah
1900 Joseph, Sevier, Utah, USA with Leah (from findmypast, not found on ancestry)
1910 Joseph, Sevier, Utah, USA with two wives, Lear and Margaret

Information from findagrave web site
From the History of the Church; vol 3 page 125: From the Journal of Kirtland Camp:
"Saturday, August 11, 1838. . . In the fore part of the night Sarah Emily, daughter of Dominicus CARTER, aged about two years and three months, died, being the fourth one the destroyer took from our midst.
Sunday, August 12. . . At two p.m. the funeral of Elder CARTER's child was attended..." This took place while they were camped "on the banks of Mad river in Green county, five and one half miles from Dayton... distance from Kirtland, two hundred and fifty-one miles."

1850 Pottawattamie, Iowa, USA. Dominicus CARTER (44) Blacksmith born Maine, Mary (20) (wife?) born New York, Sidney (14) born Maine, Lydia (12) born Ohio all places USA and Polly MINOR (18). (Sidney and Lydia were children of wife Lydia SMITH)
Information from findagrave website
Here is her death record in the Salt Lake County Death Register:
pg 10 #377 Peck, Lydia Ann. Wife of Edwin M. Born 15 Feb 1838 Kirtland Ohio. Died 8 Dec 1853. [cause of death column is blank] Place of Interment: plat B block 2 lot 2

Information from findagrave web site
GENDER: The family records of some Carter descendants have the gender of this child as male. Others have the gender as female. The fact is that Dominicus did not state the gender of this child in his record (he simply wrote the word "Baby"). Nor is there any other historical record about the birth. The early histories about the event simply refer to "the child," and later attempts to assign either male or female gender can only be considered guesses.

1850 Not found
1860 Great Salt Lake City Ward 17, Great Salt Lake, Utah Territory, USA. Living as SNIDER with mother and step father John SNIDER
Information from findagrave web site
OBITUARY: Box Elder News 28 November 1912:
PARK VALLEY RESIDENT DIES
Sometime early Tuesday morning the spirit of Mr. E. F. CARTER of Park Valley passed to the other life after he had been confined to his bed for many weary weeks during which time he was helpless and for the most part speechless as a result of paralytic strokes which afflicted him at intervals.
Mr. CARTER's trouble began over a year ago when his left leg became affected and circulation ceased. He was then in a very precarious condition, little hope being entertained for his recovery. The limb was amputated, however, and Mr. Carter recovered nicely from the effects of the operation and was feeling pretty much himself again, being about on crutches and looking after his interests, when he suffered a paralytic stroke which rendered one side of his body useless. He improved however, and gave promise of a recovery when he suffered the second stroke and since that time has had them at frequent intervals. His power of speech became lost, though he could recognize his family and friends and nod his approval of their actions, and he was also unable to eat anything. For a number of weeks not a morsel of solid food passed his lips but he took nourishment in the shape of wine, coffee and other stimulants.
The writer, in company with Pres. W. C. HORSLEY called upon Mr. CARTER on the 12 inst., and though he was unable to speak, he nodded recognition and struggled to whisper goodbye when we left him.
Erastus F. CARTER was one of the prominent men of Park Valley and has been a resident of that section for many years. Through judicious manipulation of his affairs, he was a cattle and sheepman, he has acquired considerable of this world's goods and owns a great many acres of land. For many years Mr. CARTER was the Notary Public of Park Valley attending to all real estate transactions and other matters of a legal character which required the services of a notary.
He leaves a wife and many sons and daughter as well as a great many grand children. The News extends condolences to the bereaved family, whose relationship affects many of the families in the valley.
He was my 2nd great grandfather.

Information from findagrave
Isaac Morley CARTER was born while his parents were crossing the plains and died as an infant. He is buried out there somewhere on the Mormon Pioneer trail.

Information from findagrave web site
My source on this child is the book "Carter Pioneers of Provo Utah," which has a lot of errors. He is not included in the "Xerox copy of a typewritten copy of a handwritten copy of what purported to be an exact copy of 'Uncle Dominicus CARTER's records.'" But neither is the child that Sophronia Babcock lost about the same time. 1849 was a hard time for keeping records, especially in what was then called Kanesville (Winter Quarters) where the child is said to have been born and died. The book's source on this child appears to be family group records submitted by the descendants of Mary DURFEE to the author of the book. He is not found in the lists of deaths at the Winter Quarters Project website, but their lists are acknowledged to be incomplete.

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine,
USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12) . Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
I believe they had a child Ray C STEWART born about 1890

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12) . Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah, Utah, USA
1900 Preston, Oneida, Idaho, USA
1910 St Joseph, Oneida, Idaho, USA with brother Warren CARTER
1920 Riverdale, Franklin, Idaho, USA. . With daughter Ethel BARRINGTON née CARTER and her husband and family.

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of
Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah
All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Living next door to father Dominicus CARTER

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
Information from findagrave website
DEATH DATE: Some sources have his death date as 15 November 1921 but I used the date on the death certificate and the burial record.

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Living next door to father
1900 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Children Kate 11 (June 1888), Maud 9 (June 1890), Ray L 7 (February 1893_, Heberc C 3 (March 1897) and Kimball E 1 (February 1899). All born Utah, USA

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA . Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine,
USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.
1910 St Joseph, Oneida, Idaho, USA with brother George D CARTER
1920 Sunshine, Tooele, Utah

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Payson, Utah County, Utah, USA Children Herby aged 1 and Ruby aged 9 months both born Utah, USA
1900 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA, Children Ruby aged 20 and Harold aged 12 both born Utah, USA
Information for George TAYLOR
George Taylor had been married twice before he married Phoebe CARTER and there a lot of children for these marriages, which at present I have not added, or the two marriages.

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living in a row were Dominicus with wife Mary and 9 children as above. Next door to them was Polly (38) with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). Next door to them was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer). Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Children Don Calros aged 9, George A aged 8, Hannah aged 6, Clarence aged 4, Fred aged 3, Juniue aged 1. With the family was an Edith BULWINKLE aged 16 born Utah at school.
1900 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Doewn as Newell and Frances KNIGHT with children all down as CLARK as Sterling aged 17, Earnest aged 15, Spencer aged 14 and Dean aged 10.
There were at least 11 children for Frances and her first husband. Joseph had another marriage at the same time and from this wife he had at least 11 children. I do not think Frances had any children from her second marriage. Newall had also been married before and had had at least 7 children from that marriage.

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah;
(Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Living one side of Polly and the children were Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Polly was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7)
(and a Labourer) and Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Not found at present
1900 Precincts 3, 11, 19, and 15, Graham, Arizona Territory
1910 Precinct 11, Graham, Arizona, USA
1920 Clifton, Greenlee, Arizona, USA

Information from findagrave web site
BIRTH: Her name and birth date appear on "a Xerox copy of a typewritten copy of a handwritten copy of what purported to be an exact copy of 'Uncle Dominicus CARTER's records.'" In the list her birth date is given as 27 Nov 1855 and her mother is listed as Polly Miner.
DEATH: Deseret News Weekly of Salt Lake City, Utah 29 Oct 1856:
"Died, Provo, 04 Oct 1856, Harriet M daughter of Domincus and Polly CARTER, 10 months 7 days."
She is probably buried in an unmarked grave in the CARTER family lot of the Provo Cemetery, but I have not found a burial record for her. Please correct me if I'm wrong!

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown 1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA, Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Living one side of Polly and the children were Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Polly was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer) and Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) born New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses wer Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.
1900 Silver City, Juab County, Utah, USA
1910 Eureka, Juab, Utah, USA. Daughter Zora was married to a TALLOT (TALBOT) not with family and had a daughter Eveline aged 2bonr Utah, USA
1920 Salt Lake City Ward 5, Salt Lake, Utah, USA

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Frances (33) born England with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of Polly MILNER), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances). Living next to Frances was: Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living next to her was Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home (No confirmation as yet that Louisa, Samuel, Parley and Arthur belong to Frances)
Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother (so she remarried) but shown born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. LIving in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6). All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Living one side of Polly and the children were Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12) . Living the other side of Polly was Elizabeth (38) with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7) (and a Labourer) and Next door to them was Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA as Alma Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) born New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.

1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA as William. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. LIving in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) born New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James with another of Dominicus's wives, Fanny, living the other side.
1900 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA
1910 Ward 3, Utah County, Utah, USA
1920 Ward 3, Utah County, Utah, USA
1930 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA No child with them.
1940 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA as a widower. Living next door to Sterling and then Claud (sons of Frances NASH) CARTER Living with him was daughter Lucille and her husband

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living one side of Elizabeth was:
Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was:
Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Elizabeth was: Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of
Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home" Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living one side of Elizabeth was:
Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Elizabeth was: Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah. (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER (7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11) Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living one side of Elizabeth was:
Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12) . Living the other side of Elizabeth was: Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1900 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA
Notes for Ezra CARTER:
Collins 7829 Family Tree from ancestry.com as Ezra as a son of Mary DURFEE.
Familygrave web site has Ezra as a son of Elizabeth BROWN
Mary DURFEE had another son in 1859 so until advised otherwise Ezra has been included as a son of Elizabeth BROWN

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living one side of Elizabeth was:
Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home", Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Elizabeth was: Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home", Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living one side of Elizabeth was:
Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA, Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12). Living the other side of Elizabeth was: Frances (33) with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of DURFEE), Louisa (6)
and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (76) born Maine, USA. Elizabeth CARTER (45) Keeping House, born New York, USA; Ilus CARTER at Home (9) and John F. CARTER (16) Works on Farm both born Utah, USA
1900 Lake View, Utah County, Utah, USA
1910 Cold Springs, Elmore, Idaho, USA
1920 Pleasant View, Utah County, Utah, USA
1930 Pleasant View, Utah County, Utah, USA

1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Dominicus CARTER (76) born Maine, USA. Elizabeth CARTER (45) Keeping House, born New York, USA; Ilus CARTER at Home (9) and John F. CARTER (16) Works on Farm both born Utah, USA

1860 Provo, Utah, Utah Territory, USA as BATIE the name of step-father
and
1860 Grantsville, Tooele, Utah Territory, USA. Living with Caroline HUBBARD all the PERRY and CARTER children had the
name HUBBARD, William BEATTY (30) Comml Labourer born New York, USA was living with them as well as Elisha (22) Farm Labourer born Michigan, USA and Marshall HUBBARD (14) born Illinois, USA
1870 Not found

1860 Provo, Utah, Utah Territory, USA as Cara and as BATIE the name of step-father
and
1860 Grantsville, Tooele, Utah Territory, USA, as Melissa. Living with Caroline HUBBARD all the PERRY and CARTER children had the name HUBBARD
William BEATTY (30) Comml Labourer born New York, USA was living with them as well as Elisha (22) Farm Labourer born Michigan, USA and Marshall HUBBARD (14) born Illinois, USA
1900 Springville, Utah, Utah, USA. (as Melissa)
1910 Springville Ward 1, Utah County, Utah, USA

1860 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Domincus CARTER (54) born Maine, USA. Wives Mary (née DURFEE) CARTER (30) born New York; Polly (née MINER) CARTER (28) born Ohio; Elizth (née BROWN) CARTER (27) born Ohio; Fanny (née NASH) CARTER (23) born England; Children: (Mary's) - Mary J CARTER (10) born Iowa; Geo CARTER (8) born Utah; Edmond CARTER. (6) born Utah; Jas CARTER (4) born Utah; Ena (Ezra) CARTER (1) born Utah (son of Elizabeth BROWN); Heber CARTER (1) born Utah; Warren CARTER (4/12) Utah (Polly's) - Frances CARTER (7) born Utah; Polly A CARTER (2) born Utah; Albt CARTER
(7/12) born Utah; (Elizabeth's) - Enos CARTER (6) born Utah; Maria CARTER (4) born Utah; (Fanny's) - Frankin CARTER (1) born Utah. All except Fanny née NASH born USA. Living with them were Asa AVERY (17) born Iowa, USA, Hanna AVERY (74) born Maine, USA and Jno COMINS (55) Labourer born Unknown
1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home" Frances (33) born England with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of Polly MILNER), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances). Living next to Frances was: Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA
Living next to her was Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA as Frank, Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home. (No confirmation as yet that Samuel or Parley belong to Frances). Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother (so she remarried) but shown born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James
1900 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA
1910 Provo Ward 3, Utah County, Utah, USA
Living next door was son Claud
1920 Provo Ward 3, Utah County, Utah, USA as Frank
1930 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA as Frank

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home". Frances (33) born England with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of Polly MILNER), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances). Living next to Frances was: Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7) Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living next to her was Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home". Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home (No confirmation as yet that Samuel or Parley belong to Frances). Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother (so she remarried) but shown born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James
1900 Not found (with Daniel EBERSOLE)
1910 Not found (with John BATZEN)
1920 Not found (as BATZEN)
1930 Not found (with James Peter SORENS*N)

1870 Provo Ward 2, Utah County, Utah, USA. All Children born Utah, USA and all "At Home" Frances (33) born England with Franklin (11), Fanny (9) (possibly daughter of Polly MILNER), Louisa (6) and Samuel (as yet not proven to be a son of Frances). Living next to Frances was: Elizabeth CARTER (38) born Michigan with Enos (16), Mariah (15), Ezra (11), Hannah (8) and John F (7). Living with them was Marconi(?) STEWART (32) labourer born Illinois, USA. Living next to her was Polly CARTER (38) born New York with Polly (12), Albert (10), Alma (6) and next door to Polly was: Dominicus CARTER (64) born Maine, USA. Mary CARTER (40) Keeping House born New York, USA ; all children shown "at home" Mary Jane CARTER (20) born Iowa, USA; all other children were born Utah, USA George CARTER (18); Edmond CARTER (16); James CARTER (14); Heber CARTER (12); Warren CARTER (10); Pheobe CARTER (8); Charles CARTER (2) and Marian CARTER (6/12)
1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home (No confirmation as yet that Samuel or Parley belong to Frances). Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother (so she remarried) but shown born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER, Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA/ Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James
1900 Not found

1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home. (No confirmation as yet that Samuel or Parley belong to Frances). Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother (so she remarried) but shown born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER. Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. LIving in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James
1901 Magrath, Alberta, The Territories, Canada
1911 Medicine Hat, Alberta, Canada
1914 March Applications for admission from Port of Sweet Grass, Montana to St Albans, Vermont, USA. But all the family are shown as Irish! Parley P (42), Ann C (35) wife, Ruby (12), Lemuel (10), Vernal (7) and Cornelius 3)
1917 3 November Manifest Alberta, Canada, Admissions at the Port of Coutts Albt (?). Parley CARTER (47) Farmer Lemuel CARTER (14) son Vernal CARTER (12) son
1920 Not found
1930 Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA
1940 Red Bluff, Tehama, California, USA
Notes for Parley Pratt CARTER:
Parley was not found on the findagrave website where I have found the names of all the other mothers, so I am still unable to confirm from a primary source that he is the son of Frances. However, the 18 trees on ancestry for Parley CARTER all show his mother as Frances. Still not proven but he has been left as her son until other information is received.

1880 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA. Fanny (Frances née NASH) born England, Children all born Utah, USA. Frank (Franklin) CARTER (21) Labourer, Fannie CARTER (19) At Home (was this Frances daughter of Polly MILNER, see 1870); Louisa CARTER (16) Works in Woollen Mill; Samuel CARTER (12) At home; Parley CARTER (9) At Home and Arthur CARTER (5) At Home. (No confirmation as yet that Samuel or Parley belong to Frances). Living with them was Eliza CLARKSON (67) mother (so she remarried) but shown born Utah, USA (but looks as if ditto marks put in for all family). Living next door were two more of the wives of Dominicus CARTER Polly (née MINER) born Ohio, USA, Children born Utah, USA. Polly (48) Keeping House and children: Albert (20) Miner, Alma (14) Works on Farm and William (Joseph William) (10) At Home. Living in same property were: Mary (née DURFEE) BORN New York, USA, Children born Utah, USA Mary (50) Keeping House and children: Warren (19) Labourer and Charles (13) At Home. Living in the next two houses were Mary's sons George (Dominicus) and James
1900 Not found
1910 Not found
1920 Provo Ward 5, Utah County, Utah, USA
1930 Provo, Utah County, Utah, USA
1940 Not found

I do not know if I am going to manage to put on all the information for this CARTER/DAVIES chart, it would appear that Domincus CARTER had nine wives and around 40 children, having several wives at the same time. When he died Frances married again, so it becomes a very complicated chart. At present I have put on all the marriages and all the children for Domincus and Frances and I have started putting children on for the other wives.
Some of the wives above remarried and had children, it is impossible to show this on the chart above but I will comment in the notes for the relevant wife when I get to them.

It is impossible to show for the children which ones belonged to which wife and Domincus and as he was married to more than one wife at a time it is difficult to know which children belonged to which wife, I have put in italic in a separate row, who we think the child's mother was.

I think I now have the basis for this chart on, ie all the wives and all the children we have found to date with marriages for those we have found marriages for and boxes on for those that had children, lot of additional information still to be added.

Many of the people the children married also had other wives, but at the present time I have on the following charts (in almost all cases) just shown the children for the CARTER marriage. There are so many children from other marriages it is virtually impossible to show them all in the format I have evolved over the year.

This is a Chart for Domincus Carter, Lydia Smith, Sophronia Babcock, Sylvia Ameretta Meacham, Mary Ette Durfee, Eliza Babcock Polly Milner, Elizabeth Brown, Caroline Marie Hubbard, Frances Nash and William Henry Davis

This is a Chart for Domincus Carter, Lydia Smith, Sophronia Babcock, Sylvia Ameretta Meacham, Mary Ette Durfee, Eliza Babcock
Polly Milner, Elizabeth Brown, Caroline Marie Hubbard, Frances Nash and William Henry Davis